DO NOT OVERDOSE THEM ON DEWORMER! You could easily kill them by giving them too much wormer.
Basically what happens if you overdose them on dewormer is all of the worms die at once. That sounds like a good thing, but all of the worms dying together will clog up the intestines and cause colic. This is no ordinary colic, either, it almost always requires surgery to fix and a lot of horses never recover. On top of the colic risks, some dewormers are toxic if too much is given.
Don't even give them a full dose of dewormer at first. Start them on a daily dewormer (feed-through) for a month or so, then start deworming slowly. None of what you have will work for them right now, you need to go buy a powdered daily dewormer that you add to the grain. It will be a slow improvement but it won't cause a shock to the system and they won't colic from it.
http://fuglyhorseoftheday.blogspot.com/2009/06/thats-not-mini-its-baby-worm-incubator.html
This blog explains a lot about deworming... to quote the blog
"Sometimes parasite infestation is so severe that worms can be seen in the horse's feces. This should be seen as an urgent situation - you need to get on top of it but you have to be careful. It is absolutely true that blasting a heavily infested horse with a strong dewormer may result in colic. This is because all of the worms dying at once can form an impaction in the intestines. There are various opinions on the best way to prevent this. I personally agree with starting a horse like this on daily dewormer like Strongid C because it's a mild dose - unlikely to shock their system in any way. Then, a few weeks into rehab, you can either go with a Panacur Powerpac (considered the best by most, but more expensive) or give a normal tube of Strongid. A month later, an Ivermectin and that should get most horses pretty "cleaned out" after which they can resume a normal rotational deworming program. "
EDIT--- it's fine not to grain them, but they really need the powdered daily dewormer so their systems don't get shocked. You could either take a syringe and water the powder down and give them the syringe with daily wormer in it (as a paste), or you could take it and mix it in with a small handful of grain. A handful of sweetfeed never did any harm, plus your skinny arab/qh mare could probably use some grain.